I haven’t seen my nephew since Christmas, so I took him out for some errands this weekend, thereby giving us some needed catch-up time and his parents some needed alone time. For reference, G (as my nephew will be called) is my sister’s only child. He’s 14, and he’s going through the awkward stages of puberty. This means he towers over his mom now, walks with a little uncertainty, and his voice is hovering two octaves below his uncle Ben’s. Where’s the time gone, man?
For a little more about G, he is autistic; he often addresses
his elder family members by their first names (his mom is ‘Gina’); he often stammers
through his thoughts in a halting, stream-of-conscious way. For example, when
asked if he thought homeschooling was a good idea, his response was this:
G: Kinda. I think it is… well, A) they don’t have to be… eh.. and I mean.. eh.. I’m not sure, I guess, I’m going to totally,.. I do… Yeah, I really do not think… eh, I will… [sigh]
Take your time.
For this reason, I will simplify the conversation we had for expediency, as I would like to share his thoughts on our education system with you, dear reader. At times he is contradictory. At others, quite pensive. He gives no full answers, but he’s brutally honest in his attempts. I tried to keep my inputs to a minimum, and I prodded mostly to keep him on topic. I have left some tangents along for context and flavor. [some of my inner thoughts are available, too].
Here’s how it went down: Driving down 460, I asked him “How’s school going, G?,” and he promptly dove into a dialog about the current conditions of learning in the school system, beginning with [wait for it] assessments – our current class topic! I realized how interesting this might be for some, so I asked if I could record. He agreed but continued talking before I could fully capture his next sentence. It began along these lines: “Grades are killing learning, Uncle Ben. They should do away with grades and create…”
B: Wait, what? We need to ‘create more _’ what?
G: World preparation centers. We need world preparation centers.
B: What are ‘world preparation centers?’
G: I guess they help students to prepare for the world.
B: And you think there should be more of them?
G: I think they should exist.
[you heard it here first, folks. make it happen and send the kid some college cash.]
G: One should exist, and we’ll see how that does with students… [long pause] I guess school technically is. I think we are entering a new age – the information age, or something. And, I think technology is helping learning. I mean, there’s online school, and more and more students are being home-schooled… [long pause]
B: And you think that’s a good thing?
G: Kinda. I think it is. Well… [sigh]
B: Take your time.
[See what I did there?
G dives into a long discussion of the political climate, a favorite topic of
his, and he states our country needs better people in the world.]
B: How do you suspect we get better people?
G: I don’t know. We should educate them better. Yeah, we need to educate them. And we need to stop teaching them stuff they don’t need. And we need to teach them stuff that they do need. People may not like school, so maybe we should have school… be important. We should try to fix school in some ways, I guess. Like, remember when you woke up early to go school?
B: Yeah. [I still get up early to go to school, but that’s beside the point].
G: Well, I hear that some schools in the UK are being asked to shift their school days an hour or two forward.
G: Because at different stages of your life you have different sleep cycles. And, like, people around my age generally continue to sleep through the early part of the morning and don’t even start learning until later, like mid-morning.
B: What kinds of things do think students are learning that they don’t need?
G: I don’t know. [long sigh] I guess maybe school has its purpose. Let me ask you this, Ben: Do you think learning about the fact that the mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell that important?
B: It is if you’re a biologist.
B: It’s good to know it’s out there.
G: I guess. Maybe we do need… I think…
B: I mean, in truth, I’ve never used it in my life. I do understand it a little bit, but… I’ve never had to use it.
G: I guess some people might have to use it. I guess school does have its purpose.
[We were just starting
to make our exit]
G: By the way, I think tests are absolute… ugh! Maybe schools should stop worrying about tests. Because seriously, grades make students feel like they need to worry about grades. And I’m like, students shouldn’t have to worry. Students shouldn’t let grades define them.
B: Where are you learning this stuff?
G: I don’t know. I think I’m trying to do a little research in what people think of school, I guess.
G: And, I think Ameri…
[G proceeds to go hard
on the president and his policies. G is not a fan of Trump, much to the
happiness of his parents and to the chagrins of (some of) his grandparents. After
the venting and much fine toeing of strong language boundaries, he mellowed into
more typical teenager subjects of Kid Cudi, the Chili Peppers, Eminem, Facebook
and Instagram. We were somewhere near Lowe’s when he picked up the thread
again. And once again, I hit record in the middle of the action…]
G: It makes children feel like grades define who they are, even though they don’t. I mean, I know Gina told me to try the best I can, [but] I always dreaded… most kids are worried about, or always say, ‘what’s going to be on the test?’
B: That’s true.
G: Eh, it’s just, I think school needs to teach more important things and have less tests. According to Google, tests can help children memorize, but… but I’m not sure if we should necessarily have, … [He loses his thought
at the red light. I try to steer back into the lane.]
B: So, with the tests, did you ever feel that you were trying to study for the grades and only for the grades? Or were you actually enjoying what you were trying to learn? I mean…
G: I felt like I was just studying for the grades.
G: Yeah. I guess it just felt like I had to learn it. I’m glad my mother was like, ‘Just try your best.’ I’m glad my mom didn’t get absolutely furious with me when I got a bad test score.
B: When did you get a bad test score?
G: I think I’ve gotten a couple bad ones throughout my school years.
B: Okay. [long pause]
B: So how do you learn? What’s the best way that you learn? What are you finding that’s most effective for you?
G: Um… I … I honestly don’t know. I guess when I was in home-school… Gina is really passionate about me learning. And, I kinda feel like I should be learning?
B: Okay, but do you want to?
G: Eh, no. I’m not really into that, but I’m like, ‘okay, I’ll look up this, and I’ll look up that.’ Some of the stuff that Gina wanted me look up was actually useful. However, some of it wasn’t… Gina says she’s not a good teacher… and I understand that [she’s] probably not a good teacher… but I really do think she could teach me a few life lessons. Actually, she does, and when she does teach me life lessons… I think she does a good job of that… I gue… yeah… [the struggle is real with this kid!]. I don’t know.…
[extra long pause]
All rivers must run their course. Our conversation was coming to an end. He later told me that his friends and his aides, the persons who guided him through the public school system, were the best resources he had for the enjoyment of learning. A quick note: after failing an SOL in 2017, G was required to spend his summer in school – no time for free play. His anxiety shot through the roof, and he could no longer focus without heavy medication and therapy. My sister applied for the Homebound program and pulled him out of public school. He has been in the program ever since and done well. He’s dropped most of his medications and doesn’t have to see his therapist so often. He is involved with his life and wants to make changes for the better. I’m so proud!
But, this also comes at the expense of not learning with his peers. This coming fall, he plans to attend an “alternative” school system, which shows promise to his interests, his well-being, and his abilities. It is my understanding they promote an emergent adaptive learning system, and I hope they are responsive to my nephew’s inquisitive mind. Anything has to be better than the traditional prescription. I look forward to his next report.
B: Thanks, G. We’ll catch up later.
G: Bye, Uncle Ben.