Comment on “Is Google making us stupid?” Living in the age of technophobia by Meghan Beardsley

I find that “full potential” claim interesting. Do we not sacrifice some of our potential by letting computers take the wheel on certain things? I do not really have an opinion on either side of this, but I am curious what other people would think about it. Do computers take on the archival role that allows us to think further with less “foundational” work if you will?

Comment on Attention! Can I have your attention please! by Meghan Beardsley

I definitely feel a kindred spirit thing here regarding the entirety of your post. I wanted to focus on one thing though. You mention how taking a Digital Sabbath from time to time can be good, but will people let us? I feel like if I step away from my phone for more than 3 hours I come back to texts like “Where are you? Are you mad?”, voicemails from my mom envisioning my death, and then demanding emails from my academic department piling on work. I would like to address the third one I mentioned. While I like my field, it does not save lives if you will. I cannot understand why there has to be such an immediacy in work and responses. Why do I get an email at midnight on Saturday demanding I do something that has no urgency to it, but yet they expect me to do it by 1 am Sunday? If I suggested a Digital Sabbath, then they would tell me I do not take my work seriously. It is just the opposite. I take my work seriously, but I do not want it to run my life. I do not want to be glued to my computer or phone. I would much rather run off into the fields on my weekends.

Comment on “No, I don’t think that is necessary” by Meghan Beardsley

Wow! Reading your post really opened my eyes to stuff that I think I inadvertently knew, but never stood face to face with. It is amazing the encounters you have gone through in your education and your child’s. The whole principal anecdote is particularly disheartening, and I kind of hope is an exception and not the rule, but I fear it is the latter.

Comment on On Movie Nights by Meghan Beardsley

As an obsessive movie watcher and collector, I thank you for encouraging people to use movies in the way you have described. They can have such a wonderful power and influence if brought into the correct light. There is more than one way to fuel a dialogue between people, and movies can serve as a safe space even for those who might feel vulnerable in a general discussion-based environment. Also, nice job using Lee.

Comment on Review old things with a new eye by Meghan Beardsley

Hi,

You are not the first visiting student to mention that they grew up in a “passive education system” where the teacher’s word is law. I have several friends in my graduate-level cohorts who sincerely struggled with the graduate-level course work because it demanded active learning and discussion. They told me it was difficult accepting that it was no longer a “be taught” kind of world”. I wonder what would be the best of both worlds.