I find it really interesting that you touch on real learning once you arrived at graduate school. I experienced the same issues. I was in a topic study class where we were reading and analyzing academic papers. I was amazed by the students (3rd and 4th year Ph.D students) poking holes in other peer reviewed papers. Since I have been taught since birth that academia teaches you things while you sit in a seat until you are smart enough to stand in front of a class and teach it yourself. Once you are that smart, you write about it. Challenging others ideas and thoughts never crossed my mind. I resonate with you point.
LikeLike