Comment on Corn teaches us about diversity (or the consequences of the lack of diversity) by Z. Gould

I love this analogy. Monoculture made so much sense when our society was smitten with industrial agriculture and our progress in dominating global food markets. Now I much prefer the ideas of agroforestry and agroecology where biodiversity is exalted for its resilience and our crop systems can take advantage of natural symbioses in the soil and with other organisms in the ecosystem. Our tendency with industry is alway to simplify things down to the minimum amount of parts, to make hugely complex systems seem more manageable. The whole NPK fertilization scheme is an example of this. I think our educational system suffers from the same oversimplification. We want our organizations to run like machines, meaning our teachers and their curriculums become like mechanical components. Students are just inputs and outputs, hopefully somewhat smarter or more prepared for careers after graduation, but not paid any particular attention as individual learners. The quality controls are all standardized in the forms of quizzes and examinations.

There is certainly some sort of analogous “agroecological” educational model out there that embraces student diversity and individuality and is stronger and more effective because of it. Challenging yourself to learn more about diversity is the best step toward this model’s implementation. It is not necessarily going to be the easiest nor the most economical means to educate the masses, but it will certainly be the most affective from a systems perspective and probably the most fulfilling as well.

Comment on Presenting the Present State of Writing Statements by Z. Gould

Yes Amy I agree completely that the continuity of a commitment to diversity is crucial! As I mentioned in response to Bethany’s comment, My post was more of a commentary on the fact that the Present is often left out of the picture completely. I am just ‘filling in the blanks’ so to speak- emphasizing the present tense because it is so often omitted completely. I agree thought that the past and future are also crucial in demonstrating the full arch of an educator’s commitment to inclusivity in the classroom.

Like

Comment on Presenting the Present State of Writing Statements by Z. Gould

It is a great question, Bethany. I agree we need past and present to place us contextually and give us an opportunity to adjust and learn as we go. My post is more of a commentary on the fact that the present is completely ignored in the prompts for these types of writing statements. A balance is definitely needed and ideally it is a balance that includes the proactive present as well as the past and the future.

Like

Comment on Who Knows How to Use a Screw Driver? by Z. Gould

The teaching as cooking analogy is great. Building upon skills and applying them to new challenges is so important. In the field of Artificial Intelligence a high school student just broke ground in teaching an artificial neural network to apply lessons from one training to another skill. In this case it was taught how to apply different limb movements to actions like crawling and walking and then used that information on its own to better navigate mazes. See link here: https://www.wired.com/story/meet-the-high-schooler-shaking-up-artificial-intelligence/

The key here is that there is always more than one way to do something. A tool can be designed to be used a certain way, but there very well may be better, different ways to utilized in different scenarios.

Like

Comment on The Racist Highway by Z. Gould

Grace- I agree we should be aware of word choice. “Ethnic” has several definitions but the one I intended was “characteristic of or belonging to a non-Western cultural tradition”. It is certainly relative and I believe the word can also be used to denote any origin by birth or descent that differs from a present residence or nationality. The word can certainly have negative connotations but its divisive quality actually reinforces my point. Our reaction to and perception of this “ethnic” diversity is what is important, and some of my friends have been forced to change their names because of the deeply engrained prejudices our culture has about race.

Like

Comment on On Being a Bird of Space by Z. Gould

Yes regardless of the profession I think finding your authentic professional self starts with finding your authentic personal self. This gets back to some of the mindfulness and awareness techniques we have discussed in previous weeks. In Buddhism the ultimate goal is actually seeing the sameness in your own self and the Universal Self- all other beings, objects, and ideas. This might make for some monotonous lectures when translated to teaching but would certainly facilitate the compassion necessary for quality learning.

By the way I think Debussy was getting at the same idea of breviloquence when he said “music is the silence between the notes”.

Like

Comment on Grading system is a giant monster by Z. Gould

Yes intimidation is much less important than inspiring a love of learning. Students who are ‘forced’ to learn by being chased through textbooks and exercises will never develop the independent curiosity and passion needed to become a life long learner. In our rapidly changing world this is what will keep you on top- not being intimidated by parents and teachers to excel on one static test that seems to be stuck in the past.

Like

Comment on Being Mindful on McAfee Knob by Z. Gould

I like how you mentioned the Bird’s Eye View. This is interesting to me for two reasons. 1.) A common visualization in meditation is the idea of looking at yourself from above. Just observing yourself breath as a spectator. This is a necessary tactic to help us escape constantly getting caught up in thoughts. 2.) Remote sensing in agricultural science is now giving that bird’s eye view of ecological systems in the form of data. I just learned about the NEON database where they have an enormous collection of hyperspectral imaging data from drone flights above forests and crop lands. The insights to be gained from this new scientific perspective could be incredible. I have also been meaning to make it out to McAfee’s knob. Now it seems I have even more to gain from the view.