Comment on The Humane Part of Education by Zhanyu (Grace)

I really liked “It is true that sometimes we teach unconsciously by just influencing students by who we are. But to become that person who can teach students unconsciously, the person needs to be trained.” I think whether we like it or not, just by standing in front of a class or facilitating, some students may look up to the instructor as a role model. I think educators need to recognize that they themselves have to demonstrate good character and professional ethics. This may require “training” and a good amount of self-reflection. Great post!

Comment on Again, TEACHING & COOKING by Zhanyu (Grace)

So the food analogies continue! And I like them. I would say that sometimes education could be an acquired taste. Students may not respond well to something an instructor does at first, but slowly over time, they may change their minds. We probably have all had courses that we disliked while taking it, but then in retrospect, thanked ourselves for going through with it because we learned something. And I’ll take you up on your cooking offer =).

Comment on Time to Put a Bow on it by Zhanyu (Grace)

Hi Sara, thank you for sharing! I enjoyed reading your takeaways from this course, and it’s good to see you being so optimistic about bring innovation to the classroom. I’m still trying to figure out how I can implement some of the techniques for teaching engineering classes; perhaps traditional methods aren’t so bad…it’s really up to us to determine what might work best. This week’s readings, along with Miguel Andre’s and Ethan’s posts, also got me thinking about student character development. It seems we have some more work to do in fostering not only critical and creative thinking but also empathy and emotional intelligence. Part of it is what you mentioned about being able to gracefully agree/disagree. Again, great post!

Comment on Empathy is the new black by Zhanyu (Grace)

I’ll have to look more closely about the statistic that engineering students have the lowest levels of empathy. It’s definitely alarming, but I am not surprised either. For a profession that has to deal with many different stakeholders, and where communication is so important, one would think empathy holds a higher place in education. Instead, anything remotely bordering on “feelings” is not discussed. (See Ethan’s post on GE complaining to RPI about the quality of “human beings” graduating from engineering.) I think there is a need for engineering education to emphasize communication, and not only “engineering communication.”

Comment on Reflection & Refraction by Zhanyu (Grace)

Really nice pictures! I think you hit the mark in that learning takes place over the course of one’s entire life, and perhaps learning how to learn should be the goal of teachers in helping students. The paintings you’ve shown could not have been possible without the artist making the effort to self-explore and to venture into different styles. We as students also need to explore – whether it’s taking courses in other disciplines or trying something different. Even if the results don’t turn out great, it’s important for instructors to not penalize the effort and rather reward the process.

Comment on Thoughts on Diversity by Zhanyu (Grace)

Hi Armani, I think another issue in discussing micro-aggression among student groups of the same background is that we might not acknowledge our own prejudices, whether we are Americans or international students. I have experienced micro-aggression not just from locals, but also from other international students. I think it’s only fair to say that we all need to reexamine our biases and be aware of how we perceive others who are different from ourselves.

Comment on Like Deer in Headlights by Zhanyu (Grace)

Love the pictures in this post! How should we find a happy medium? I think you’re right in that there is only so much we could do as instructors to keep students from getting distracted with their devices. It is important to remind them of how well they work with their laptops, and what it means to them in terms of learning. Ultimately, the choice is theirs. Some students may even need the laptop/other devices, due to disability or special circumstances, as Emma mentioned in her post. The problem is that sometimes a person’s laptop can become a distraction to other students. Whose responsibility is it then? How much power does an instructor have?

Comment on ENGAGING Definitions of Critical Pedagogy from Six Different Disciplines by Zhanyu (Grace)

I left a comment earlier but for some reason it didn’t show up. So hopefully this one isn’t a repeat, and I apologize if it is. I responded to the section on transportation engineering: the U.S. interstate system was built on the premise of transportation efficiency that often blatantly marginalized the poor. Unfortunately, engineers can’t/don’t always make decisions in favor of social justice simply because infrastructure projects are mired in politics and lobbying. These same engineers also have to uphold professional ethics that require them to safeguard client interest as well as public well being. Navigating through the many potential conflicts of interest is extremely complex. The question is, are students ready for real-world complexities? Can higher education serve them in tandem with the valuable experiences gained on the job? I think it’s important for students to develop a mindset that can accommodate the many uncertainties and factors/people to contend with in real-world problem solving. It’s also important to get used to not having an answer handed to them, or to the fact that sometimes there isn’t a single, right answer or an answer at all.

Like

Comment on Won’t We Need to be Able of Critical Thinking Ourselves? by Zhanyu (Grace)

Armani’s story was indeed very interesting. I also love the gif used at the end of the post. I think we need to place more emphasis on open ended problem solving in engineering education, where students spend more time finding a “good” solution rather than “the” solution. The problem solving process captures critical pedagogy because it involves obtaining and evaluating different alternatives/perspectives, cooperating among various parties, and considering broader impacts on society. I think a lot of students feel uncomfortable dealing with the uncertainties in open ended problem solving, but it is a reality that engineers must deal with by exercising their judgment and finding ways to better understand the problem.